
1. BIBLIOGRAPHY
Holm, Jennifer L. 2007. MIDDLE SCHOOL IS WORSE THAN MEATLOAF. New York : Atheneum Books for Young Readers. ISBN 0689852819
2. PLOT SUMMARY
In this story, a year in the life of seventh grader, Ginny Davis, was shown through her notes, doodles, report cards, instant messages, poems and other writings, newspaper clippings, and other small things that made up a big part of her life.
3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
This story depicted the life of a twelve-year-old girl as she experienced a difficult year. This story was unique as it was told through pictures of things such as letters, cards, bank statements, repair bills, and other small items. The reader had to go through all of these bits and pieces of Ginny's life and put them together to understand the things, both good and bad, that happened to Ginny at school and at home during the year that she was in seventh grade. Ginny went through some major changes such as gaining a new step-father and being away from her brother, Henry, who was arrested and then sent to military school. The effects of these things were seen in her dropping grades on her report cards, a disciplinary referral for slapping her former best friend for saying something unkind about Henry, and a note and business card showing an appointment to a therapist. Things started to get better for Ginny at the end of the story as Henry got ready to come back home and she won first prize at the school science fair.
The characters in this story were believable, especially Ginny, as a seventh grader trying to make sense of the happenings in her life. The letters, notes, poetry, and instant messages in this story are something that all middle school aged students can identify with. These things are a regular part of life for students in this age group, making the story very realistic. The plot is simple and believable. It was written in order from the time school started in the fall to the end of the school year where Ginny began to look forward to the summer. The setting was in a Pennsylvania town called Woodland Glen. Most of the story takes place at Woodland Central Middle School and at Ginny's home, which are the two places that most middle school aged students spend the majority of their time.
The theme of this story was that a person has to try to make the best of life, in spite of the fact that everything is always changing. Ginny went through some very difficult transitions in this story, but ended up feeling better by the end. This book was written in a style that reflects how twelve-year-olds think and act so young readers will be able to identify with Ginny and the things that happen in her life in the story. This story was written in a lighthearted matter. There are no real tragedies, with the exception of Ginny's description of the loss of her father in a car accident when she was younger.
The style of this book is unique. The detailed illustrations by Elicia Castaidi are what makes this book so special and appealing. The unique idea of telling a story through pictures of small things such as newspaper clippings, notes, and cards makes for very interesting reading. This book is perfect for middle school aged students, who will enjoy this unique reading experience.
This book has a young girl as the main character who gets through the problems and victories that life brings on a daily basis. This story would appeal to other young girls who will be able to relate to Ginny and what she thinks and feels as the story is read. This book is contemporary as it depicts the life of a modern day girl in middle school and would appeal to young adult readers.
4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
Children's Literature: "Kudos to Maryland author Jennifer Holm for such an original and touching book and to illustrator Elicia Castaldi for the pictures so revealing of Ginny’s personality."
Kirkus: "Middle-school readers will recognize Ginny's world and enjoy piecing together the plot through the bits and pieces of "stuff" depicted in Castaldi's collages. A delightful collaboration."
5. CONNECTIONS
*This book would be good to use with middle school aged students.
*Other books that would appeal to middle school aged students:
Deriso, Christine Hurley. DO-OVER. ISBN 038573333X
Klise, M. Sarah. REGARDING THE BATHROOMS: A PRIVY TO THE PAST. by Kate Klise. ISBN 0152051643
*Other books by Jennifer L. Holm:
BOSTON JANE: AN ADVENTURE. ISBN 0060287381
PENNY FROM HEAVEN. ISBN 037583687X
*Another book by Elicia Castaldi:
MISS POLLY HAS A DOLLY. Retold by Pamela Duncan Edwards. ISBN 0399238573
Holm, Jennifer L. 2007. MIDDLE SCHOOL IS WORSE THAN MEATLOAF. New York : Atheneum Books for Young Readers. ISBN 0689852819
2. PLOT SUMMARY
In this story, a year in the life of seventh grader, Ginny Davis, was shown through her notes, doodles, report cards, instant messages, poems and other writings, newspaper clippings, and other small things that made up a big part of her life.
3. CRITICAL ANALYSIS
This story depicted the life of a twelve-year-old girl as she experienced a difficult year. This story was unique as it was told through pictures of things such as letters, cards, bank statements, repair bills, and other small items. The reader had to go through all of these bits and pieces of Ginny's life and put them together to understand the things, both good and bad, that happened to Ginny at school and at home during the year that she was in seventh grade. Ginny went through some major changes such as gaining a new step-father and being away from her brother, Henry, who was arrested and then sent to military school. The effects of these things were seen in her dropping grades on her report cards, a disciplinary referral for slapping her former best friend for saying something unkind about Henry, and a note and business card showing an appointment to a therapist. Things started to get better for Ginny at the end of the story as Henry got ready to come back home and she won first prize at the school science fair.
The characters in this story were believable, especially Ginny, as a seventh grader trying to make sense of the happenings in her life. The letters, notes, poetry, and instant messages in this story are something that all middle school aged students can identify with. These things are a regular part of life for students in this age group, making the story very realistic. The plot is simple and believable. It was written in order from the time school started in the fall to the end of the school year where Ginny began to look forward to the summer. The setting was in a Pennsylvania town called Woodland Glen. Most of the story takes place at Woodland Central Middle School and at Ginny's home, which are the two places that most middle school aged students spend the majority of their time.
The theme of this story was that a person has to try to make the best of life, in spite of the fact that everything is always changing. Ginny went through some very difficult transitions in this story, but ended up feeling better by the end. This book was written in a style that reflects how twelve-year-olds think and act so young readers will be able to identify with Ginny and the things that happen in her life in the story. This story was written in a lighthearted matter. There are no real tragedies, with the exception of Ginny's description of the loss of her father in a car accident when she was younger.
The style of this book is unique. The detailed illustrations by Elicia Castaidi are what makes this book so special and appealing. The unique idea of telling a story through pictures of small things such as newspaper clippings, notes, and cards makes for very interesting reading. This book is perfect for middle school aged students, who will enjoy this unique reading experience.
This book has a young girl as the main character who gets through the problems and victories that life brings on a daily basis. This story would appeal to other young girls who will be able to relate to Ginny and what she thinks and feels as the story is read. This book is contemporary as it depicts the life of a modern day girl in middle school and would appeal to young adult readers.
4. REVIEW EXCERPTS
Children's Literature: "Kudos to Maryland author Jennifer Holm for such an original and touching book and to illustrator Elicia Castaldi for the pictures so revealing of Ginny’s personality."
Kirkus: "Middle-school readers will recognize Ginny's world and enjoy piecing together the plot through the bits and pieces of "stuff" depicted in Castaldi's collages. A delightful collaboration."
5. CONNECTIONS
*This book would be good to use with middle school aged students.
*Other books that would appeal to middle school aged students:
Deriso, Christine Hurley. DO-OVER. ISBN 038573333X
Klise, M. Sarah. REGARDING THE BATHROOMS: A PRIVY TO THE PAST. by Kate Klise. ISBN 0152051643
*Other books by Jennifer L. Holm:
BOSTON JANE: AN ADVENTURE. ISBN 0060287381
PENNY FROM HEAVEN. ISBN 037583687X
*Another book by Elicia Castaldi:
MISS POLLY HAS A DOLLY. Retold by Pamela Duncan Edwards. ISBN 0399238573
















